generally receive positive feedback, often earning around out of 5 across major retailers like Target , Walmart , and Oreo.com . Fans love the nostalgia-inducing flavor, while critics find them significantly sweeter than the original. Key Highlights
“Solid. I wouldn't call it a rockstar, but it's very respectable. It reminds me of an original Oreo mixed with some of those frosted animal crackers.” chiefeats.food.blog · 7 years ago Buying Information buy oreo birthday cake
Users on community forums and retail sites have shared mixed but passionate experiences: I wouldn't call it a rockstar, but it's very respectable
: The cookies are frequently praised for their "fun" look, featuring rainbow sprinkles embedded in the creme and celebratory designs on the wafers. Purists may find the cake flavor too intense
: A common critique is that they are "unbalanced" or "sickeningly sweet" compared to standard Oreos. Purists may find the cake flavor too intense for more than one or two cookies. Consumer Feedback
: Reviewers from The Kitchn note the creme tastes "eerily similar" to store-bought confetti frosting. Some users find the chocolate cookie helps balance the "artificial" cake notes, though it can leave a slightly bitter aftertaste for some.
The product is widely available in packs. You can find them at major retailers: Target : Family Size - 17oz for approximately $5.89 . Walmart : Family Size - 17oz for approximately $4.97 . Dollar General : Family Size - 17oz for approximately $5.25 . The Best Oreo Flavors of 2025 (We Tried & Ranked 17!)