The episode follows four distinct storylines featuring Cohen’s primary characters:
: Characterized as a youthful, high-energy YouTuber, Cohen sits down with former Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio . Arpaio participates in a "toy unboxing" segment where he enthusiastically discusses the Second Amendment with a miniature plastic donut. Critique and Reception Who Is America? Season 1 - Episode 4
Critics from Vulture and The Independent noted that while the episode delivers high-cringe comedy, some segments felt less effective than previous ones. In the fourth episode of Sacha Baron Cohen’s
In the fourth episode of Sacha Baron Cohen’s satirical series Who Is America? , the comedian pushes his alter egos into increasingly surreal territory to bait public figures and business leaders into revealing their most unfiltered views. In a bizarre display, McCutcheon is seen brandishing
: The Israeli anti-terror expert trains Republican businessman Shaun McCutcheon on workplace safety. In a bizarre display, McCutcheon is seen brandishing a large ham—yelling "Here comes pork!"—as a makeshift shield against a simulated terrorist attack.
: Italian billionaire Gio Monaldo meets with a luxury yacht broker from the Luxury Yacht Sales Company . While Gio discusses using a mega-yacht for illicit activities like human trafficking and attacking refugees, the broker remains focused on closing the deal, even while witnessing Gio receive sexual favors in the same room.
: The ultra-liberal lecturer attempts to discuss pornography with David Pyne , national director of the Utah Republican Assembly. The segment reaches peak absurdity when Cain-N’Degeocello tries to "reclaim" derogatory terms and presents a graphic educational book featuring rabbits.