: Both artists often sported heavily kohl-rimmed eyes and a specific, pained falsetto-meets-punk vocal delivery.
: Because Esther was positioned directly behind Charli on the drums or synths, casual viewers at festivals like Glastonbury often did a double-take, thinking they were seeing a mirror image of the singer. Evolution of the Look
Should we look into other or more about Esther Joy’s solo music ? Why does past charli look so much like Esther f...
: They both leaned into a "messy-cool" girl aesthetic, often wearing similar bold makeup and streetwear that made them look like stylistic twins on stage.
: While Charli has been open about using Botox and fillers to maintain her look today, these changes have further distanced her current appearance from the raw, unpolished "past" version of herself that fans associated with Esther. : Both artists often sported heavily kohl-rimmed eyes
: Early in her career, Charli’s label was sometimes accused of "whitewashing" her heritage, using styling and makeup that leaned into a more generic "indie girl" look.
The persistent comparison between "past Charli" ( Charli XCX ) and —her former drummer and collaborator—is one of those deep-cut fan theories rooted in more than just a coincidence. : They both leaned into a "messy-cool" girl
Fans often debate how Charli’s look has changed over the years. Some suggest that "past Charli" looked more like Esther because: